The item beside this text is an advertisement

QUILLBLOG

Filed under: Quillblog, , ,

Related posts

No related posts.

Gzowski family responds to controversial bio

The revelations contained in the first full-length biography of journalist and broadcaster Peter Gzowski are beginning to provoke a backlash.

R.B. Fleming’s Peter Gzowski: A Biography (Dundurn Press) contains many uncomfortable truths about the host of Morningside and The Country this Morning, who died in 2002 – that he could be cold to his guests and cruel to co-workers, that he smoked too much and struggled with alcoholism, that he had a tendency to bend the truth for the sake of a good story.

However, the biggest controversy stems from the previously unpublicized revelation that Gzowski had a child from a secret affair with a co-worker in the 1970s. A Toronto Star reporter who managed to track down Gzowski’s love child discovered that Rob Perkins now lives in Kingston, Ontario, where he manages an auto-parts store, and that the identity of his father has been something of an open secret (“I’ve talked about it openly to people I know,” Perkins says, “I just don’t brag about it”).

Now, in response to an interview with Fleming on CBC Radio’s The Current, the Gzowski family has responded to the biography’s controversial claims. In a letter read on-air on Thursday’s show, the family states:

To date, no member of our immediate family has spoken with Rae Fleming beyond telling him that we would not take part in his research. We made that choice after several people who knew our father well and who knew us called to say that they thought the questions being asked of them were mean-spirited, ill-informed and, in some cases, baffling. None of us has been interviewed about this book, nor will we be.

We feel that The Current failed to bring its usual journalistic principles to its coverage of this story. Specifically, why did the host or her producers not consider any of the sources that Fleming used for his allegations, considering Fleming’s opinions are so radically different from both the public perception and our family’s knowledge of our father?

We cherished our time with him and continue to celebrate his memories and his accomplishments. We are sorry that anyone would regard this biography as a portrait of the man we knew in private or the public man on the radio.

Globe and Mail columnist Margaret Wente has also come to the defence of “our beloved Gzowski,” arguing that if the radio host was indeed a neglectful father, it was only because he was a man of his times.

Back in the ’60s and ’70s, secret love children were a dime a dozen. Some were so secret, their own fathers didn’t even know about them. A few years ago, one 50-something man I know answered the door and was greeted by a beaming, eerily familiar-looking young fellow who announced: “Hi, Dad!”

Lots of teenage girls (Joni Mitchell, for example) had love children, too, whom they gave up for adoption before they went on to become successful women. Pierre Trudeau had a love child in old age, and was widely admired for it. Mel Lastman, a former mayor of Toronto, admitted to a long affair that allegedly produced an entire love family. He was widely thought to be a sly dog.

Wente’s broader point – that bad behaviour shouldn’t distract from Gzowski’s professional achievements – may be a good one, but lumping him in with Lastman certainly doesn’t do him any credit.

  • http://www.bureaucrat.ca That Guy

    the problem is that he was a public figure, which opens him up to a level of criticism that most don’t have to face; as for the wink-wink dime-a-dozen Madmen approach of this article, remember that you are discussing real people who didn’t have access one of their parents, which most people would consider somewhat sad and might nudge you to be more sensitive about the subject…just saying

  • http://www.shaunsmith.ca Shaun

    So, Wente’s defense against the accusation that Gzowski had a bad side is that Gzowski had a bad side?

  • Paul

    The biographer went out of his way to exaggerate his portrait of Gzowski, claiming he was a “genius” with a “dark side”. Granted, Gzowski was a fine radio host, but a genius? I don’t think so. And a few mistakes or character flaws hardly add up to a “dark side”. Gzowski was a fairly ordinary guy, who was good at his job and had imperfect relationships. But that isn’t dramatic enough to generate book sales, and so we got some artificial controversy instead.

  • R B Fleming

    Re the claim made by Alison Gzowski and siblings that they refused to speak to this “mean spirited” and “ill informed” biographer during the research and writing of Peter Gzowski, A Biography:

    Really? My email records show exchanges with Alison and Peter C. Gzowski on subjects such as family birth dates, their father’s high school records and so on. Furthermore, on 8 July 2003 Peter C. had lunch at my place, during which we discussed, among other things, my proposed biography of his father. About a week later, Peter wrote to tell me that he had been in touch with Gillian Howard, his father’s last partner. In his email, he included the following from Ms. Howard: “I suppose that a biography is inevitable, and I guess the only choice is whether it’s ‘authorized’ or ‘unauthorized’. In the first case, everyone cooperates and talks and in the second, everyone pretends it isn’t happening and bitches afterwards.” Hmmm.

    Would Peter Gzowski himself like this biography? Gillian Howard has already answered that question. “Peter’s attitude,” she wrote to Peter C. Gzowski in July 2003, “would be one of discomfort but, given that he made his living asking questions of others, he would just shrug and hope that the effort would be a well-researched and interesting portrait that people would find readable.” Well spoken.

    Rather than bitching over articles, reviews and interviews, and rather than blaming the host and producers of The Current for not having verified my sources, the children of Peter and Jennie Gzowski would do well to read the biography, including its 1,000 detailed explanatory endnotes. I guarantee that they will discover a readable, well-researched and balanced portrait of their father, whose stature in the pantheon of Canadian and international broadcasting is in no way diminished by the fact that I discovered a real human being called Peter John Gzowski.

    Sincerely, R.B. Fleming

  • David

    How delightful! Wouldn’t Peter Gzowski have enjoyed all this free publicity, born (no pun intended) out of revelations of his tendency to have human failings, as do many of us. When it comes to book sales, there is no such thing as bad publiciity, so perhaps Mr. Gzowski will savour some additional, postumous, success.

  • Greig

    RB Fleming sure has raised a hornet`s nest of comments..See blogs in The Globe & The Star..i.e. ” bottom feeder…badly written..another second rater…Kitty Kelley Lite..wrong author”..Too bad the Bloggers never got to Pages 398-511 of the book where the author details his six years of research..79 pages of Notes..13 pages of Bibliography and 4 pages of Acknowledgments. At least 5 Canadian University Archives as well as several City archives were consulted. A host of people at the CBC who had worked with Peter were forthcoming….Fleming`s penchant for getting at the facts once again shines through..Pity he has to take such a kicking…

The item directly under this text is an advertisement
Books of the year
Click to see Books of the Year 2011 package Click to see Books of the Year 2010 package
Book Pictures

Do you have great photos from a recent book event in Canada that you'd like to share with us? Submit them to the Quill & Quire Flickr pool and they'll show up here.

Brian Lam, publisher of Arsenal Pulp Press

Carol Jensson and Judie Glick at the launch of the New Granville Island Market Cookbook

Robert Ballantyne, Associate Publisher at Arsenal Pulp Press, and Wesley Yuen, old friend of Brian Lam.

Judie and Carol at the end of the launch.

Susan Safyan, editor of Arsenal Pulp Press, handing out wine at the launch of the New Granville Island Market Cookbook

the spread, contributed by the vendors at Granville Island Market in support of the New Granville Island Market Cookbook by Judie Glick and Carol Jensson

Butch choir

apple pie

adding some glisten

Gord Hill

Spartacus launch for the Anticapitalist Resistance Comic Book

History Panel

Recent comments