The item beside this text is an advertisement

QUILLBLOG

Filed under: Quillblog, , , ,

Related posts

No related posts.

Sony Reader fails to wow them at WOTS

In addition to the numerous author readings, signings, and stacks of books for sale at yesterday’s Word on the Street festival, which drew an estimated 200,000 people to Queen’s Park in Toronto, there was a new technology on display for book lovers to test drive: the Sony Reader. According to an article in the Toronto Star, WOTS director Alexandra Moorshead extended the invitation to Sony because she felt the device, which is capable of holding the text of up to 160 books and is currently the only e-reader of its kind available in Canada, would appeal to the “avid readers” who patronize the annual festival.

The good news for bibliophiles who still enjoy the experience of riffling the pages of an actual book is that, according to the people inteviewed for the Star article, it appears that she was wrong.

Samantha Lamb enjoyed a few minutes of rest in the shade with daughter Sadie, 3, as they contentedly sat surrounded by a dozen books they had just bought.

A few minutes later, a woman dressed as a cellphone walked by, encouraging her to sign up for a new cellphone book club concept.

“You can win a digital reader if you sign up,” she said, unaware that the incentive did little for these two traditionalists.

“As soon as she had the ability to turn pages, I think that is what made her love books,” said Lamb, of her daughter.

“I don’t see electronics having the same kind of magic.”

Other traditional complaints about e-book technology were trotted out, including the fact that it can’t be taken into the bath.

To their credit, Sony representatives were apparently not promoting the new reader as a replacement for traditional books, but rather as a complementary technology.

Johnny Lam, the product manager for the Sony digital reader, said the company doesn’t think books will ever be replaced altogether.

“A lot of customers still like the true essence of reading page by page,” he said.

Instead, this is being marketed as a practical solution to lugging around textbooks, and a way to survive commuter boredom.

For a detailed look at the Sony Reader and its closest competitor, Amazon’s Kindle, watch for the November issue of Q&Q, which will be available on newsstands mid-October.

  • http://sfwriter.com Robert J. Sawyer

    Actually, it’s easy to take an ebook reader to the bath or the beach. Put it in a clear baggy, or wrap it in saran wrap; it works just fine, and if you drop it in the water, it’s also just fine — unlike a paper book (the pages of which you can’t change if it’s in a plastic bag, and which gets wrecked if you drop it in the water. :)

    The Sony Reader has a very nice display (but then, so do all e-ink devices), but unlike most of its competitors, the Sony Reader does not support dictonary look-up of words while you’re reading.

    Also, Word on the Street’s timing wasn’t particularly apt for Sony this year; those who follow such things have known for weeks that Sony is planning a big announcement about ebooks for next week (rumoured to be either a new model or the addition of Wi-Fi technology to the existing model), so who the heck would buy this week?

  • http://sfwriter.com Robert J. Sawyer

    Also, Sony was selling their ebook reader at $275 at Word on the Street. Now, yes, that was marked down from the regular price of $299, but, really, was there anything else at all on sale at Word on the Street that cost even half that amount? Even a third of it? One shouldn’t read too much into small sales (if they were, in fact, small) of what was by far the biggest-ticket item on offer at the entire event. When I went by the booth (around 3:30, I think), it was packed with people, and I suspect a lot of consciousness-raising happened, even if few sales were made that day.

  • Tanya Fuller

    Okay, I love reading. Not the books. Reading. Good stories actually. The format isn’t an essential piece of that experience for me. Yes, I am aware there are people who love books. The physical part.

    For me, its the stories contained within. And that ‘within’ can be in paperback, hardcover (though a nice leather bookbinding still reeks of wealth and obviously it would be nice to have a whole library of my favourite stories in leather covers)on disk, tape, or cheap paper. So if Sony can come up with something that’s easy to read (lots of options on font size, guys),easy to carry around (books take up a lot of room in my purse not to mention the weight), and the ability to load it with any book I please, just like I can at the library, and I can afford it without having to take out a loan – then hey, yah, I’m there. Oh, and did I mention my story loving daughter would LOVE some new gadget she could both use, and show off? Make it pretty.

    That’s all.

  • parentoftwo

    So is Sony now supplying books in Canada? We bought a Reader last Christmas but haven’t been able to use it much because the Sony Store won’t download a book to a credit card with a Canadian address. THANKS A LOT SONY! Amazon Kindle is the same. Yeah, sure you can get War and Peace from the Gutenberg Project plus a number of other ancient odds and ends, but Gutenbeg files have such a ragged display on the Reader you’re soon heading down to the used book store for a paperback version. Even the approved Sony texts are torture for
    anybody who appreciates typography. Widows, orphans, bad breaks–whoever designed this thing obviously
    never heard of them. Actually, the Reader is a clumsy piece of technology. It is slow to paint the page, flashes to black at each turn in a most annoying way, has no features like searchability, internet, or dictionary. People who are used to laptops or sophisticated PDAs just won’t be ablke to fathom why it is so limited in its functionality. I believe eBooks will displace paper editions within 10 years but this clunker is not going anywhere.

  • http://www.thewordonthestreet.ca Alexandra Moorshead

    The Sony Reader Lounge was packed all day and Sony told me that they did solid sales at the festival – even with a price tag of $275. The Word On The Street crowd did not disappoint.

    With the release of any new technology, there are the innovators and early adopters that lead the way and laggards who are resistant to new ideas. The Sony Reader isn’t going to replace traditional books anytime soon but you’re out to lunch if you don’t think this product is only the beginning of what is coming.

  • David R. Filbey-Haywood

    I love books, in fact I am a bookaholic, buying $150 worth when I am supposedly visiting the book store for just one item. The walls of my home are lined with bookcases. Reading is my favourite pursuit…………………with old fashioned paper books of course not these new-fangled electronic devices. Yes, yes, I know that I can read two complete books on my Palm Pilot if I so want………………. but apart from a few bored glances over the years they don’t appeal. Did I say Palm Pilot? Well, yes, I have one of those and a desktop and three laptops so I am pretty computer savvy but electronic books??? I’ll leave those to the younger people who come along and like ducks to water take all electronic forms of traditional devices as the norm, eventually of course in the future wondering what is a “book”!

  • NSH

    Hello.
    If your eyes get tired easily as mine do, why not visit librivox.org. Sure they have only public domain works but you can find quite interesting things. I am presently listenng to Mackay’s Popular delusions after listening to Proust’s ‘A la recherche du temps perdu’. And yes the idea is Canadian.
    N.S.H.

  • Susan

    I live in Dubai where the book selection in English is limited. I started buying books online but the laptop was too hot sitting in my lap for hours in the absurd temperatures reached in this part of the world. So last summer I bought a Sony Reader and have been downloading books like crazy, I love it.

    Sure it is not the perfect system but it is wonderful to have access to books whenever you want and wherever you are. I have lived overseas for many years and I can personally tell you as an expatriot that this is the best thing to come into my life since the cell phone.

    It easily fits in my purse, can be read in the sun, and when I finish a book I can immediately start another with the push of a button. As for using Canadian Credit card I do and have done since July of 2008. No batteries, last for two days of continuous reading, just plug it into an access port of your computer and voila your off. The only problem that has to be worked out is format. Not all books are compatible with the system which can be irritating.

    All in all I think that the Reader is a great addition to todays technology and they have just started selling them here in Dubai where they sold out in days. Just goes to show there are many ways to enjoy technology.

    SJS

The item directly under this text is an advertisement
Books of the year
Click to see Books of the Year 2011 package Click to see Books of the Year 2010 package Click to see Books of the Year 2009 package
Most shared stories this week
Book Pictures

Do you have great photos from a recent book event in Canada that you'd like to share with us? Submit them to the Quill & Quire Flickr pool and they'll show up here.

a congrats to all

Rage

Jenna Tenn-Yuk

breaktime interviewing

interviewing

Danielle K.L. Gregoire

Sepideh

Elle P

sound poetry

Anita

Frances

winning

Recent comments