Comments on: Jacob Two-Two, too

By: michel

michel — Wed, 27 Aug 2008 19:27:15 +0000

jeez, relax. Nobody is erasing the original works.

Authors family’s have a right to make as much as they can during the short period that copyright is in force. If you don’t like this practice, don’t buy the books.

Taking over material from another writer has been part of literature from the beggining. It’s how things grow. Nobody is being ripped off here.

By: angel guerra

angel guerra — Tue, 26 Aug 2008 17:59:03 +0000

Because it is a long established practice–by publishers–does not make it valid. As to the platitude that writers are imposters anyway– well, that ‘makes it alright then, especially among those who have never written anything of value. Why Idoes M&S not hire Yann Martel to rewrite Ondaatje’s latest novel to make it better. Or if Atwood isn’t up to it why not hire someone to write a sequel to A Handmaid’s Tale. Because they’re alive and the living can act, take up arms, marshal lawyers and agents, and publish elsewhere in the future. But the dead, well they’ll understand�being former members of the fraternity of imposters. While Ondaatje is alive the publisher will make a show of honouring his work. Come death and sober reflection sets in then it’s time to send out a call for the rewrite man.

By: michel

michel — Tue, 26 Aug 2008 16:09:32 +0000

this is a long established practice, even if you just noticed it. It doesn’t harm the original books.

Besides, writers have always been imposters.

By: angel guerra

angel guerra — Tue, 26 Aug 2008 12:22:43 +0000

I’m not questioning whether Cary Fagan or Petricic have the talent to do a good book. I’m questioning whether authors should abet publishers in their penchant for grave robbing. It won’t take long, if it hasn’t happened already, where publishers start demanding a rewrite of novels where, for example, Anna Karenina does not kill herself. James Bond, L.M. Montgomery, and now Mordecai Richler–we are witnessing the rise of the writer as imposter.

By: patricia

patricia — Mon, 25 Aug 2008 22:19:24 +0000

Cary Fagan is a very talented writer, and Petricic an amazingly talented illustrator. Were it anyone else but these two, I would be first in line to gripe. I say hold off on the criticism until the book is released.

By: angel guerra

angel guerra — Mon, 25 Aug 2008 20:42:52 +0000

We show no respect for the dead. We root in their graves, extolling their virtues and leave a plastic lily behind as a sign of our gratitude. Cary I’m a big fan of yours but ……