The item directly under this text is an advertisement

Opinion, , , ,

Written in blood

In the wake of the massacre at Virginia Tech this week, Salon has posted a fascinating article about what creative writing professors should do when confronted with disturbing works by students. As has been widely reported, the perpetrator of the massacre, Cho Seung-Hui, wrote several scripts for his playwriting class that deeply alarmed the school’s English department faculty. Now, a lot of media pundits are questioning whether faculty could have done more to get Seung-Hui some medical treatment.

But this opens the door to a lot of potential problems, of course, the chief one being that creativity and freedom of speech could be trampled on.

Creative writing teachers have long wrestled with what they should do with students who turn in gruesome stories, as many colleges do not have formal policies about how teachers should respond. Further, there are no set rules for determining whether a story is the product of a febrile artistic imagination or a potentially violent criminal. Or both.

[...]

Creative writing teachers still have to rely on their own imprecise judgment, especially in classes where students may be encouraged to write with intense emotion. What may be one student’s cause for concern may be another’s catharsis, says Michelle Carter, [professor of creative writing at San Francisco State University]. “Sometimes working through rage in that way can be healthy,” she says.

Related posts:

  1. » The most interesting bookstores of the world
  2. » Tamaki talks voice at the Written in Colour Symposium
  3. » Event photos: The Humber School for Writers’ summer workshop
  4. » Penguin wants to suck your blood
  5. » A bit of the old ultraviolence: kids’ edition

One Response to “Written in blood”

  1. Heather Burt says:

    Interesting set of concerns. As I prepare for my summer teaching term, which will include a section of creative writing, I’ve been pondering the events at Virginia Tech and their connections (loose ones, I think) to creative writing classes. So far I’ve yet to encounter any really disturbing student stories nothing gruesome or even particularly creepy but I expect that if (when?) it does happen, I’ll be getting in touch with the college counselling services pretty darn quick.

    Regarding freedom of speech and the creative writing class, I certainly wouldn’t want to “trample” my students’ creativity, but at the same time I recognize that a college/university class is not a democracy. I determine the content, I assign the grades, and, for a variety of reasons, I give students a short (very short) list of things they’re not allowed to write about. If a student were to suggest that he or she can ONLY write, for example, hate literature or pornography, then I’d probably argue that a creative writing class isn’t the best place for that student.

The item directly under this text is an advertisement

Latest comments

  • Zachariah Wells: It’s been a while since I read it, but I thought ZN Hurston’s book tremendous.
  • Nic Boshart: I read one of DH’s short stories and loved it, thought I’d try out a novel and picked up...
  • Carl: “We don’t have anything like [Canada Reads] in Quebec.” Yes you do, it’s called Canada Reads. I...
  • urbanmkr: Yes, it is, but it doesn’t have quite such a large listenership, I guess.
  • Alex Good: “We don’t have anything like [Canada Reads] in Quebec.” Isn’t it called Le Combat des...

Latest issue

Quill & Quire cover

Inside: In the January/February issue of Q&Q, now on newsstands, we look back on the decade that was, highlighting the people, books, and events that defined the 2000s. Also in the issue, we look ahead at the season’s most anticipated books in our Spring Preview; visit with veteran publisher Kim McArthur as she attempts to reinvent McArthur & Company; and examine the secret nine-to-five lives of Canadian authors. All that, plus reviews of new books by Todd Babiak, Ruth Ohi, Ann Vanderhoof, Richard Scrimger, and more.

» Subscribe today!

Follow along and participate

Book Pictures

View all photos

Book Launch for Von Allan's "the road to god knows..." at Ottawa's Perfect Books

panel celebrates

Ottawa writers festival

Blazing Figures Launch

Blazing Figures Launch

Blazing Figures Launch

Blazing Figures Launch

Blazing Figures Launch

Blazing Figures Launch

Blazing Figures Launch

The fine print

All content copyright Quill & Quire -- Quill & Quire is a registered trademark of St. Joseph Media