The item directly under this text is an advertisement

Opinion

National Book Award dust-up continues

The shortlist for this year’s National Book Award for fiction is continuing to generate debate about the worthiness of the nominees and, ultimately, of the award itself. None of the shortlisted authors are well known, even in the literary community, and many American book commentators were left wondering why such big names as Philip Roth and Russell Banks were not nominated. (Novelist Thomas McGuane went so far as to say that the award “was tanking.”) Laura Miller has now weighed in on the debate with a thoughtful editorial in The New York Times. Miller commends the judges for not allowing the award to degenerate into a literary popularity contest, but is put off by the sameness of the shortlisted titles: “Beautiful sentences, formal experiments and infinitely delicate evocations of emotional states abound in these five books, but those woebegone souls in search of a good story will have to keep looking, elsewhere.”

Related links:
Read Laura Miller’s editorial in The New York Times

Related posts:

  1. » Bookmarks: The Advent Book Blog helps you shop, The National Post picks a shadow Canada Reads list, and more
  2. » Claudia Dey, Patrick Lane nominated for Amazon.ca First Novel Award
  3. » Event photos: Edna Staebler Award
  4. » Andrew Nikiforuk becomes first Canadian to win prestigious environment book award
  5. » Photos from the Toronto Book Awards shortlist announcement

Comments are closed.

The item directly under this text is an advertisement

Latest comments

  • Nic Boshart: I read one of DH’s short stories and loved it, thought I’d try out a novel and picked up...
  • Carl: “We don’t have anything like [Canada Reads] in Quebec.” Yes you do, it’s called Canada Reads. I...
  • urbanmkr: Yes, it is, but it doesn’t have quite such a large listenership, I guess.
  • Alex Good: “We don’t have anything like [Canada Reads] in Quebec.” Isn’t it called Le Combat des...
  • angel guerra: It costs just the same…..? What a bargain. Makes writing War and Peace sound like a piece of...

Latest issue

Quill & Quire cover

Inside: In the January/February issue of Q&Q, now on newsstands, we look back on the decade that was, highlighting the people, books, and events that defined the 2000s. Also in the issue, we look ahead at the season’s most anticipated books in our Spring Preview; visit with veteran publisher Kim McArthur as she attempts to reinvent McArthur & Company; and examine the secret nine-to-five lives of Canadian authors. All that, plus reviews of new books by Todd Babiak, Ruth Ohi, Ann Vanderhoof, Richard Scrimger, and more.

» Subscribe today!

Follow along and participate

Book Pictures

View all photos

Book Launch for Von Allan's "the road to god knows..." at Ottawa's Perfect Books

panel celebrates

Ottawa writers festival

Blazing Figures Launch

Blazing Figures Launch

Blazing Figures Launch

Blazing Figures Launch

Blazing Figures Launch

Blazing Figures Launch

Blazing Figures Launch

The fine print

All content copyright Quill & Quire -- Quill & Quire is a registered trademark of St. Joseph Media